The Best Toasters Ovens of 2026, Tried and Tested

Finding the right toaster oven can change how you cook at home. These small but mighty kitchen helpers do more than just brown bread. They bake, roast, broil, and some even air fry your favorite foods. After spending weeks testing different models, we’ve put together this guide to help you pick the perfect one for your kitchen.

Why You Need a Toaster Oven

Toaster ovens have become must-have items in modern kitchens. They heat up much faster than your regular oven, which saves time when you’re rushing to get dinner ready. During summer months, they’re a lifesaver because they don’t heat up your entire kitchen like a full-size oven does.

The best part? These appliances are incredibly flexible. You can cook multiple dishes at the same time, reheat leftovers without making them soggy, and even roast a whole chicken if you get the right size. Many people now use their toaster ovens as their main cooking appliance, especially if they live alone or with just one other person.

What Makes a Great Toaster Oven

After testing over 20 different toaster ovens, we learned what separates the good ones from the disappointing ones. Here’s what really matters when you’re shopping for one.

Smart Controls Make Life Easier

Digital screens beat old-style knobs every time. When your toaster oven has a clear digital display, you can see exactly how much time is left and adjust it easily if needed. The timer shuts off automatically when your food is done, so you won’t burn your breakfast if you get distracted.

Some cheaper models use basic dial timers with just a few numbers marked on them. These make it really hard to set an exact cooking time. Even worse, they don’t turn off on their own. If you forget to check on your food, you’ll end up with burnt toast or overcooked pizza.

The best toaster ovens let you change the temperature in small steps, like one or five degrees at a time. This gives you much better control over your cooking. Avoid models that only let you adjust temperature in big jumps of 25 degrees.

Safety Features That Matter

Toaster ovens get incredibly hot when they’re running. The outside surfaces, including the top and door, can reach temperatures that will burn your skin if you touch them by accident. This is especially important if you have kids in the house.

Better quality toaster ovens have doors with metal frames around them. These frames stay much cooler than plain glass doors. They also usually have springs that prevent the door from flopping open too fast when you pull the handle. This small detail makes a huge difference in daily use and helps prevent accidents.

Even Cooking Is Non-Negotiable

Your toaster oven should cook food evenly from edge to edge. Nothing is more frustrating than pulling out toast where one side is perfectly golden and the other side is still pale. The same goes for frozen pizza or anything else you cook.

Good toaster ovens don’t have hot spots. When you fill the rack with bread and toast it all at once, every piece should come out looking pretty much the same. This means the heating elements are placed correctly and the oven design promotes even heat distribution.

Speed Matters for Toast

Here’s something interesting: toaster ovens are slower at making toast than pop-up toasters. But some toaster ovens are much faster than others. The average time to make medium-brown toast is around four minutes. Some models can do it in under three minutes, while others take more than six minutes.

Two or three extra minutes might not sound like much, but when you’re trying to get out the door in the morning, every minute counts. Faster toasting usually means better heating elements and smarter temperature control.

Convection Fans Speed Up Everything

The top-performing toaster ovens all have powerful fans built in. These fans blow hot air around your food, which does two great things. First, it makes everything cook more evenly. Second, it cuts down cooking time by five to ten minutes for most recipes.

This feature is especially good for getting crispy results. French fries come out golden and crunchy instead of soggy. Roasted chicken gets beautifully browned skin. Cookies bake perfectly. The strong air circulation makes a real difference in how your food turns out.

Top Picks for Different Needs

Best Overall: Breville Smart Oven Pro

This toaster oven does everything well. It toasts bread evenly in about four minutes, bakes pot pies without cold spots, and the powerful convection fan helps cook food faster and more evenly. The generous size means you can actually roast a whole chicken in it, which makes it work great as a backup to your main oven.

The digital controls are easy to understand and adjust. You can change the temperature and time while food is cooking, which is really handy when you need to add a few more minutes or boost the heat at the end.

The downside is its size. At almost 20 inches wide and 16 inches deep, this takes up serious counter space. You’ll need to make sure you have room for it. The convection fan is also pretty loud when it’s running at full power.

Best for Air Frying: Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro

If you want one appliance that does both toaster oven tasks and air frying, this is your best bet. The dial controls make it simple to switch between the many functions it offers. You can adjust temperature and time in tiny increments while cooking, which gives you precise control.

The super convection setting creates amazing air-fried results. French fries get crispy on all sides, and chicken wings come out perfectly cooked with crunchy skin. It’s also great at regular toaster oven jobs like baking and roasting.

One small issue: it tends to make slightly pale toast. But this is easy to fix by just adding a bit more time with a quick turn of the dial.

Best Compact Option: Breville Mini Smart Oven

Not everyone has space for a huge toaster oven. This smaller model fits better on crowded counters but still handles most cooking tasks well. It heats up incredibly fast, just over a minute to reach 400 degrees. Four slices of bread fit comfortably for toast, and frozen pizza comes out with crispy crust and melted cheese.

The simple button controls for temperature and the settings dial are straightforward to use. For under $160, this is a solid choice if you don’t need all the fancy features of pricier models.

The trade-off for the smaller size is that it won’t fit a 12-inch pizza. Also, toast on the right side came out a bit lighter than bread on the left side during testing.

Best Mid-Size: Breville Compact Smart Oven

This model hits a sweet spot between the Mini and the full-size Pro. It’s big enough to toast six pieces of bread at once and fits a 12-inch pizza. The cooking results are impressive, pot pies come out golden brown and fully heated through, with no cold spots or burnt edges.

The dials for changing settings are simple and make sense. You don’t need to read the manual to figure out how to use this oven.

However, the door is solid glass without a metal frame, so the edges get hot. There’s also no interior light. When toasting six slices at once, the bread around the edges turns out lighter than the pieces in the middle.

Best for Reviving Bread: Balmuda Toaster Oven

This unique steam oven is perfect if you love fresh-tasting bread and pastries. You add a small amount of water through an opening on top, and the oven injects steam while cooking. This creates toast with a crispy outside and a soft, almost bread-pudding texture inside. It’s amazing for reviving day-old bread or croissants.

The design is beautiful and compact, so it doesn’t hog counter space. It excels at evenly browning toast and broiling cheese until it’s perfectly melted and bubbly.

The small size is both good and bad. It saves space but only fits two slices of toast at a time. During testing, a 10-inch pizza had to be cut in half to fit. The analog controls work fine but aren’t as precise as digital displays.

Best Large Capacity: Breville Joule Oven Air Fryer Pro

This spacious oven can fit a 14-pound turkey if you wanted to cook one. It handles baking, roasting, toasting, and air frying with excellent results. The “add more time” function is really convenient, and you can set oddly specific temperatures if you feel like it.

Some people love the connected app, which reminds you when to flip or turn food. Others never bother with the app and just use the oven’s controls. Either way works fine.

The toast function shows some spotty browning, though it still does an acceptable job. The biggest drawback is the price, this is an expensive appliance.

Toaster Oven vs Regular Pop-Up Toaster

Should you get a toaster oven or stick with a traditional pop-up toaster? The answer depends on your needs, budget, and kitchen space.

Toaster ovens are more versatile. They can roast vegetables, bake cookies, reheat pizza, broil cheese, and yes, make toast. Many people use them instead of their main oven because they preheat in a fraction of the time. During hot weather, they don’t turn your kitchen into a sauna like running your big oven does.

Pop-up toasters do one thing: toast bread. But they do it really well, and they’re much faster at it than any toaster oven. They’re also smaller and cheaper. If you have limited counter space or truly only need to toast bread, a good pop-up toaster is a smart choice.

If you can only buy one appliance and want something that does multiple jobs, go with a toaster oven. If you already have a toaster oven but find yourself waiting forever for toast in the morning, adding a pop-up toaster makes sense.

How to Choose the Right Size

Toaster ovens come in different sizes, and picking the right one matters. Think about what you’ll actually cook in it.

Small toaster ovens (fitting 2-4 slices of toast) work well for single people or couples who mainly want to reheat leftovers and make toast. They take up less counter space, which is great for tiny kitchens.

Medium toaster ovens (fitting 4-6 slices of toast) are the sweet spot for most families. They’re big enough to bake a small casserole or roast vegetables for dinner but don’t dominate your counter.

Large toaster ovens (fitting 6+ slices of toast) can replace your main oven for everyday cooking. You can roast whole chickens, bake full batches of cookies, or cook multiple dishes at once. Just make sure you have the counter space and don’t mind the higher price tag.

Key Features to Look For

Temperature Range

Your toaster oven should reach at least 450 degrees. This lets you broil food properly and get nicely browned results. Some models max out at 400 degrees, which limits what you can cook.

Look for models that let you adjust temperature in small steps. Being able to set 365 degrees instead of being stuck with 350 or 375 gives you better control over recipes.

Timer Function

A good timer is essential. Digital timers that count down and turn off automatically are way better than manual dial timers. You want to see exactly how much time is left without guessing.

Some cheaper models max out at 20 or 25 minutes. This isn’t long enough for many recipes. Make sure the timer goes up to at least 60 minutes, preferably longer.

Interior Light

Being able to see inside your toaster oven without opening the door is really helpful. You can check if cookies are browning or if cheese is bubbling without letting heat escape. Not all models have this feature, but it’s worth paying extra for if you bake often.

Accessories Included

Better toaster ovens come with useful accessories. Look for:

• Multiple oven racks (so you can cook more at once)
• A baking pan
• A broiling rack
• A pizza pan
• An air fryer basket (if the model has air fry function)
• A crumb tray that slides out easily

Having these accessories included saves you from buying them separately later.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Buying Too Small

Many people buy a compact toaster oven to save counter space, then get frustrated when they can’t fit a full pizza or roast a chicken. Think about what you’ll actually cook and size up if needed. A toaster oven that’s too small won’t get much use.

Ignoring Safety Features

Cheaper models with glass doors that have no metal frames get dangerously hot. If you have kids or tend to move quickly in the kitchen, spending more for better safety features is worth it. Burnt fingers are no joke.

Skipping Convection

Toaster ovens with convection fans cost more, but they’re worth the extra money. Food cooks faster and more evenly. If you plan to use your toaster oven regularly, the time savings add up.

Not Measuring Your Space

Measure your counter space before buying. Some toaster ovens are huge and might not fit where you want to put them. Also think about clearance above the oven, you need space for heat to escape from the top.

Maintenance Tips

Taking care of your toaster oven keeps it working well for years.

Clean the crumb tray after every few uses. Crumbs build up fast and can start to burn, making your kitchen smell bad. Most crumb trays slide out easily for quick cleaning.

Wipe down the interior once a week if you use it daily. Let the oven cool completely first. Use a damp cloth with a bit of dish soap. Avoid harsh chemicals that might damage the heating elements.

Clean the door glass regularly so you can see inside. A mix of baking soda and water works great for baked-on splatters.

Don’t forget to clean accessories like racks and pans. Most are dishwasher safe, which makes cleanup easy.

Final Thoughts

The right toaster oven makes cooking at home easier and more enjoyable. After testing dozens of models, the Breville Smart Oven Pro stands out as the best all-around choice for most people. It does everything well, has easy-to-use controls, and the powerful convection fan cuts down cooking time significantly.

If you want air frying capabilities, the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro delivers excellent results. For smaller kitchens, the Breville Mini Smart Oven or Compact Smart Oven provide good performance without taking up too much space.

Whatever you choose, focus on these key features: even cooking, digital controls with automatic shutoff, safety features like insulated doors, and a convection fan if your budget allows. These elements make the difference between a toaster oven you use every day and one that sits unused on your counter.

Remember that a good toaster oven is an investment in your kitchen. It should last for years and make countless meals easier to prepare. Take time to find one that fits your needs, your space, and your budget. Your future self will thank you every time you pull out perfectly cooked food in half the time.

Frequently Asked Questions: